« Addiction - Part II | Main | Lordy, Lordy... NetNewsWire, how I love thee! »

OpenOffice on OS X/Mac

    For some time I have been airing my complaints about Microsoft's current licensing schemes (on this weblog and another I work on). My biggest complaint has to do with the cost for a small business like the one I work in to a) keep up with the newer software products that come out* and b) that the software unit of Microsoft is essentially subsidizing the operations like MSN and theOpen Office (the free version of StarOffice). I also got around to...

...finally installing Open Office on my PowerBook (Mac). It took a while to figure out how to get the thing running properly in X (you can't run it natively on Aqua) - but the time spent was mainly because I refused to read the installation notes. No, Open Office is not for novices - especially on the Mac. With RedHat, it was part of the installation...
    My first impressions are pretty good. I remember testing StarOffice some years ago and was honestly disgusted. I didn't like the interface and I didn't like how slowly the program responded. I also didn't like the fact that interoperability between MS Office and StarOffice was poor. Many people were able to use both applications without problems, but usually it was due to the fact that they were not using many of the high-end formatting options available in Office and copied by StarOffice. Therein lies the issue, in my opinion.
    If I want to use Office as a type of layout program where I can transfer data seamlessly between components like Word and Excel, then maybe the cost can really be justified. If I use Office, however, for basic document writing and maybe some low-level spreadsheet work, I don't feel that the cost is justified. The only reason that remains for us to keep Office around is because we want to be able to read stuff that our clients are sending us (assuming they use Office, too). At some point, however, you need to say enough is enough. The technology has gotten far enough these days that creating a PDF out of a normal document has become possible. Look at the fact that such an option is offered on the Mac's right out of the box (and I think XP now, too) -- and now that I just looked, it appears that RedHat can do the same. We all know (or should know) that PDF's are as versatile as any document - anyone and almost anything can read one (and that's more than Office can claim). So, why continue using Office? Two reasons (and these reasons are becoming less and less relevant): a) everyone uses Office and b) we want to use what everyone else is using because of interoperability issues. As discussed above, a is especially becoming less and less relevant.
    In the end, I don't see enough reason to keep me paying for Office and I would imagine a great number of people out there are in the same boat. Why not give Open Office a spin? It won't cost you anything - to begin with - and you just may be as pleasantly surprised as I! I have found my experiences with Open Office on the Mac to be nothing short of surprising. I still haven't encountered any situations where the program has crashed (which has been complained about from time to time by other users), so I can say that it does work under the type of load I put on it.
    Suffice it to say, that I wouldn't be surprised if we finally have a viable alternative to Office. It looks like the past 5 years of StarOffice/Open Office development has paid off. Now we need to get some actual use out of the program to show that it works.

*Whether we actually need to perform these upgrades is debatable, but if I want to keep up with my clients (most of which are very large and have much more money than I), then I have to somehow accept this financial burden. At least, I think I do. I have learned that while some may be surprised that you can't do a certain thing because of technological limitations, there are very few who aren't willing to live with it, IF you can provide them a product they need in an efficient and cost-effective manner. So, the need to upgrade is more emotional than it is real.

Comments (3)

dave:

Hi, I was wondering how you've found Open Office, performance-wise under OS X. I'm running MS Office on my dual G4 500 and find it disappointingly slow and sluggish, especially when editing documents and switching between applications. -DC

I find the performance of OpenOffice more than acceptable on both my 12" PowerBook and 17" PowerBook (one is my wife's and the other is mine). I find the performance better than Office - without a doubt. Office is oddly sluggish when doing editing operations - I have none of these problems when using OpenOffice. I have both software products on my machine, however, as I have a lot of documents that are Word formatted that end up somewhat garbled in OO. I still would recommend trying it out. As the weeks pass, I am finding it less and less necessary to open Office/Word.

One caveat is that you cannot cut and paste between XFree86 programs and OS X native/Aqua programs. Therefore, you cannot cut-n-paste from TextEdit and Open Office. I forget this at times, but the inconvenience is worth the fact that I am slowly freeing myself of Office molasses.

Elentar:

It is actually possible to copy and paste between X11 apps and native OS X apps. Within X11 itself, select some text to temporarily put it into a clipboard of sorts - to paste it somewhere, hold down Option and click the mouse (emulates a middle-button click). Within many apps, Control-C and Control-V will copy and paste as well.

To paste text from X11 into OS X, select it in X11 and use the normal Command-C to copy it. You can then paste it into a normal OS X app (but not to X11). And to paste text into X11 from OS X, copy it like normal and use the Option-Click technique to paste it.

-Elentar

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on February 16, 2003 9:58 AM.

The previous post in this blog was Addiction - Part II.

The next post in this blog is Lordy, Lordy... NetNewsWire, how I love thee!.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.